The 25 best catchers in MLB The Show ranked by True Overall and Meta Overall ratings. Compare blocking, arm strength, and hitting stats.
Top 25
Adley Rutschman
All-Star
90.96
Cal Raleigh
Live
90.55
Jason Varitek
Egg Hunt
90.30
Joe Mauer
All-Star
90.18
Will Smith
World Baseball Classic
Austin Wells
World Baseball Classic
Ivan Rodriguez
All-Star
Harry Ford
World Baseball Classic
Mike Napoli
Egg Hunt
Joe Mack
Spring Breakout
Rainiel Rodriguez
Spring Breakout
Mike Piazza
Jolt
Ted Simmons
Jolt
William Contreras
World Baseball Classic
Alejandro Kirk
World Baseball Classic
Salvador Perez
World Baseball Classic
James McCann
St. Patrick's Day
Cal Raleigh
World Baseball Classic
Will Smith
Live
Roy Campanella
The Negro Leagues
Willson Contreras
World Baseball Classic
Kyle Teel
World Baseball Classic
Shea Langeliers
Live
Alex Hall
World Baseball Classic
